Round 13
Saturday
2.30pm, 29 April
Saints v
Cowboys
Venue: Dairy Farmers Stadium, NQ
 Saints on TV 2000
Match Preview
& Team
Match 
Report & Results
TV / Video Capture
This Weeks

Sound File
Scrapbook
Referee Rating
PREVIEW:
Cellar dwellers, NQ have found form and are proving to be a fly in the ointment for a number of high rollers in the 2000 comp.

Saints have had a difficult month with the loss of Brian Johnston, Lance Thompson, and now Anthony Mundine + Choc controversy. But if we look back, we have had a good month on the field with 3 wins and one loss so far in April.

With a number of danger players and on home turf, the Cowboys are a difficult proposition. However, they have a number of players out and a quick look at the teams suggest strongly that Saints have the goods to win this game and win it well as long as we get rid of the 15 minute nap.

Luke Branighan, still an unknown, will cause havoc and Chris Leikvoll has been promoted to the run-on team in place of Thommo. Julian O'Niell is positioned in the centres opposite Jamie Ainscough and that lends itself to a fine stand off. But the reality is that both players can be found all over the pitch and I expect to see a far more entertaining battle between O'Niell and Trent Barrett.

This should be a top match with a lot of players lifting to the call against a more than keen Cowboys team.

Saints by 13.

The ref for this match is Mark Oaten who clobbered Saints in round seven vs Auckland - 8 penalties to 1 . But it was also our best win of the year and ref Oaten received a better than average rating.


FOOTY TAB:
Cowboys 4.5 start
ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA DRAGONS
TEAMS
NTH QUEENSLAND COWBOYS

Luke Patten
Nathan Blacklock
Jamie Ainscough
Shaun Timmins
Mark Gasnier
Luke Branighan*
Trent Barrett*
Chris Leikvoll
Nathan Brown(c)
Craig Smith(c)
Darren Treacy
Luke Bailey
Wayne Bartrim
Res:


Terry Lamey**
Corey Pearson
Andrew Hart
Jason Hooper


1
2


3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Res:
14
15
16
17


Tim Brasher(c)
Adam Connelly
Julian O'Niell
Paul Bowman
Scott Donald
Scott Prince
Paul Green
John Buttigieg
Lee McWilliams
Mark Lockey
Mark Shipway
Kyle Warren
Jeremy Schloss
Res:
Nathan Fien
Peter Jones
Glenn Morrison


Robert Relf

*Late number changes: Barrett wearing #6, Branighan wearing #7
**Terry Lamey late withdrawal. Robbie Simpson (#19) in.


FULLTIME SCORE: Saints   4 - Cowboys 50
Match Conditions: 28 degrees C, fine, good breeze favour NQ first half.
Attendance: 13,768
MATCH SUMMARY:
SAINTS ANNIHILATED 50 - 4
                 In what is turning out to be one of our worse years, Saints were crushed today
                 by the last placed North Queensland Cowboys by a mammoth 46 point
                 margin. 
                 Saints were firm favourites to take out this encounter. The locals in Townsville
                 were hoping for a good showing from their team. No one expected the hiding
                 which was to take place. 
                 For most of the match, Saints had less than 30 % of the ball. This was mainly
                 due to their lack of ball control and an obvious inability to properly complete
                 their sets of six. 
                 At half time, the score was 32-0 and although we picked up a trickle of
                 possession in the 2nd half, it was a shell-shocked Dragons team which took to
                 the field for the final 40 minutes. 
                 On top of being thrashed, Saints also have to face the music on Tuesday night
                 with both Craig Smith and Darren Treacy on report. Although Treacy (late
                 tackle) seems to have enough in his favour to mount a defense, Smithy (head
                 high) looks to be in strife. He has already been suspended once this year. 
                 Bartrim was sin binned for dissent  for the 2nd week running as he took out his
                 frustration on the ref, blurting out one expletive too many. He would have been
                 better off concentrating on the game plan as only a few of the Dragons showed
                 up to play and most were just plain lazy, especially in defense. 
                 In all fairness, the Cowboys were pretty to watch today and were clearly a
                 team full of beans. With the worse attack record in the NRL, the Cowboys
                 have now posted 2 scores of 50 points this year. 
                 The Dragons now have to re-group once again and will front the inevitable
                 crappy tabloid controversy of the 'Mundine factor' which may or may not have 
                 contributed to their loss. Even when the guy isn't at the party, he will be
                 accused of making too much noise. As far as I could see, the only thing which
                 contributed to this latest Dragons' loss was a lack of basic effort.

FULL MATCH REPORT:

Saints applied the early pressure with Timmins looking dangerous but the NQ line held firm. Saints' defence, on the other couldn't mark up when NQ scored a soft try in the 8th minute
Score: 6-0

What followed was a procession of NQ tries, mostly under the posts and mainly resulting from feeble defensive work, especially up the middle of the ruck.

Needless to say, NQ took full advantage of these opportunities and everything went right for them. NQ had some luck with the bounce of the ball and the luck usually went the way of the locals but the reality is that they were 10 times more enthusiastic then their visitors.

When Saints did get the ball, they meekly gave it up with poor ball control and woeful kicking options. On one occasion when Saints really needed to dig deep, the ball carrier, Ainscough was unimpressive when  tackled into touch about 20 metres out from  Saints' tryline. The Dragons' defenders made NQ look good when they let in yet another soft try and mid way through the first half, NQ were scoring an average of a point a minute. After 23 minutes and with only 23% of the ball, Saints just couldn't mount anything that even slightly resembled a contest.

It was around the 30 minute mark that we noticed the frustration of the day starting to get to team members. This mainly manifested itself into panic play and handling errors but there were also a few late tackles, a little bit of head hunting and too much arguing with the ref. An example of this was when Barto came back on after a spell and immediately tried to start a dust up. This lack of discipline became more apparent as the match went on and was one of the many contributing factors as to why we copped such a hiding.

Saints threw a few moves together and were looking capable of scoring if not for some poor finishing. But a few minutes before the break, Brasher scored a blistering try off the boot, kicking  ahead and re-gathering. With everything going NQ's way, it was heart breaking to watch...these are the sort of tries that we want to see Saints scoring. By the time half time had come around we had had just about enough but we knew that we would all be glued to the match after the break, hoping for a miracle.

HALF TIME SCORE: SAINTS 0 - NTH QLD 32

Saints started the 2nd half miserably with a simple handling error one pass after the kick off. But they regrouped in determined fashion and had clearly put the previous 40 minutes behind them. A try or two in the next 10 minutes would give us some hope and there was talk of Saints pulling off a remarkable comeback. Smith, Treacy and Bailey worked hard up the middle while Barrett and Branighan tried hard to mobilise their outside men. Unfortunately, Saints' best scoring opportunity of the match went begging when Ainscough looked to where he expected his unmarked winger to be only to see the touch judge - Blacklock hopelessly out of position.

Nevertheless, Saints got their first back to back sets of six early in the second half and some positive things were happening. Top quality work from Barrett saw Smith in a gap and we would have scored if 1, he passed the ball quickly to an unopposed Bartrim or 2, he backed himself once the tryline was only 2 metres away and Brasher was desperately hanging on. Instead, he sent out a forward pass and another try was bombed. A minute later, Craig Smith was on report for a high tackle and will probably find himself sidelined after he fronts the judges on Tuesday night. He will almost certainly get suspended.

Seven minutes into the 2nd half,  NQ lose the ball on halfway and Saints have possession again. From about 40 metres out, we thought once again that we see the boys mount a fresh attacking raid with Luke Bailey and Chris Leikvoll driving it forward. We were denied a try when the ref ruled Luke Branighan offside as he touched down after a Nathan Brown kick into the in-goal. I watched this back a few times and it is inconclusive because Branighan is out of shot. But the angle of his run suggests that he would have been OK. There was no vid ref called and there should have been a call for a 2nd look. But whatever way you look, this was another opportunity biting the dust. 

On the subject of Luke Branighan, we are all pretty impressed by this new young half back who is recent weeks has come close to scoring a number of times in a team which is performing well below par. He sets up many plays and has laid on a few tries, his kicking game is top notch, he offloads consistently while drawing 2 or more defenders and he also defends well against blokes twice his size. Its only a matter of time before Luke starts to get a few tries next to his name and we hope that he stays a Dragon for a long time.

Well, like I said, we had our chances early on in the 2nd half and hoped for a revival. Sadly, it was NQ who scored in the 49th minute courtesy of a forward pass to the NQ winger, Connelly who had no trouble getting around Timmins. Connelly's opposite man, Mark Gasnier is nowhere to be seen. The try was orchestrated by Paul Green who put up a mid field bomb. An oversupply of  Saints players (including Gasnier) were all in the middle of the paddock and they all looked at each other as the ball bounced into a NQ players hands who sent it wide to the try scorer. The O'Niell conversion from out wide hits the post and goes in.
Score: 38-0

In the next set, NQ score what might be the try of the year with a 60 metre effort passing through many hands and ending with Paul Green touching down next to the sticks. Green also had an early hand in starting the movement which was instigated by NQ simply having the numbers in the backline. The real turning of this match was somewhere in the first 20 minutes but tries in the 49th and 53rd minutes puts the match beyond any doubt. The conversion attempt hits the posts again and like before goes through for the extra 2 points.
Score: 44-0

In the 55th minute, Luke Branighan charges down a kick in mid-field and Saints have the ball. Bartrim takes it up and takes exception to being tackled. Darren Treacy then takes it up making good ground. Barrett and Bartrim combine to get the ball closer to the NQ line and Saints look to be on a roll. Bartrim once again takes issue about being put to the ground, lashing out when in playing the ball. The final play comes to naught after a forward pass but at least Saints are having a go. 

In the meantime, Bartrim and Relf are having a go at each other in the back play and the ref intervenes. Bartrim carries it on and the ref calls him over again. This time there is a touchie report but it was looking like a nothing situation with perhaps a penalty at worse. Unfortunately, Barto acted like a peanut by talking crap and swearing at the ref. With team mates dragging him away, Bartrim is sent off for 10 minutes. Listen up Barto - you're a drongo! I know you must have some off field hassles but we don't bring our home problems to work and we don't bring our work problems home. For 2 weeks running you have let your team down by reducing them to just 12 defenders. You look like a bloke out of control. Wake up to yourself !

At 44-0 down and with only 12 men it was a case of just waiting for the next NQ try to be scored. With 2 penalties in a row the Cowboys look specials but somehow the Dragons hold firm and defend better than at any other time in the match. Gasnier leapt high and took a bomb with confidence earning a relieving penalty as O'Niell tackled him in mid air. NQ get the ball soon after but once again Saints defend well close to their line. Back in possession, Saints show some enterprise in attack and play their best footy of the day. A good set of six, followed by a good kick, followed by some heavy defensive work close to their opponent's line and forcing the NQ error and getting a penalty to boot ! Sadly, Saints crucify the try chance when they knock on and we lose possession. But the lead up was good. In fact, during this 10 minute period (55-65min), Saints do well and we can only wonder why they were unable to consistently put in the hard yards for the other 70 minutes of the match.

For the rest of the match, Saints played on equal footing to their opposition. Both teams coming up with one try each in the final 15 - 20 minutes.

In the 64th minute Saints score the try which could have been scored an hour earlier. Trent Barrett found a gap and put on a simple step to run through. Jason Hooper who has backed up all day was on hand to score 15 m left of the up rights. A few players came up to congratulate Hooper but the rest of the team just went back to their positions, happy enough that we were at last on the board. With Barto sin binned, Thommo out for the year and Ainscough off the field, it was up to Tingha to attempt the conversion which was unsuccessful.
Score: 44-4

NQ attacked the Saints line continuously for the final 10 -15 minutes and would have scored if not for the Tingha snatching the ball out of a potential try scorer's arms after a bomb and later when a NQ try was disallowed when Brasher ran the some 80 metres only to be penalised for stealing the ball from a tackled Brown. Once again, Saints got the ball back and looked OK, almost scoring a couple of times - we look and wonder as to why we were thrashed when for the last quarter of the match, we actually looked the better team.

With less than 5 minutes to go, Darren Treacy is put on report for a 'very late' tackle but it looks OK. The penalty is warranted but  it would be surprising to see Treacy cop a suspension. The penalty gives NQ an opportunity and in the 77th minute they score the final try of the match.

Before we came into this match we thought that there might be some complacency. We thought that with all the hassles which have dogged us us in recent months that there would have been a good reason to put in a less than average show. After all, team morale can't be the best. We all knew that when we sat down and tuned in for the Saturday match at 2.30 that we might be watching a Dragons team who will win in a less than convincing fashion.

Instead it was a nightmare.

The Cowboys played well and looked like winners from early on. They can't win the comp but they deserve to be better than wooden spooners.

Saints in contrast were frustrating us. What we have here is a team in trouble and it has been my displeasure to endure these losses in slow motion. We have to rally more than ever - these bad times are temporary.

FULL TIME SCORE: 50-4

Saints Best
3- Bailey, 2-Hooper, 1- Branighan


Stats: 








Jamie Ainscough looking for his winger

Craig Smith

The bench looks on

Bartrim being restrained and removed


Tingha has a rare opportunity to stretch out

Our only try...





Trent Barrett sums it all up with 2 minutes to go


SOUND FILES NOW ON MP3 FORMAT
MP3 files are compressed without loss of quality. 
MP3 is faster to download which means we can bring you more sound!
If you don't have an MP3 player then you should get one now.
CLICK HERE: Winamp MP3 player
The Winamp player set up (476 Kb) will only take a few minutes to download and less than one minute to install.
BEST OF ALL, IT'S FREE!!
We've been using Winamp's MP3 player now for ages now.
MP3 is becoming more & more popular.
It's a great way to listen to music and other sound files.
NB: Some browsers may have plugs-in which conflict with sound file downloads.

The best way to download sound files is to right-click on the speaker and use the 'save link as' (or similar) option, saving the file to your desktop or folder of choice.
If you continue to experience difficulties, please let us know. email the webmaster
Click on the speaker to hear 
Craig Smith interviewed by Phil Blake


429 Kb .mp3 file

Sorry, no scrap book this week...

REFEREE & TOUCH JUDGES & VID REF
REFEREE: Mark Oaten
Total Referee or Touch Judge errors = 5
Errors in favour of Saints = 2
Errors in favour of  Cowboys = 3
Penalty Count: Saints 7 - Cowboys 10
Comments:

Apart from a string of penalties against the Dragons late in the first half and a couple of rough calls early in the 2nd half, we didn't have too many problems with Mark Oaten - the match having been won and lost in the opening 20 minutes.  I thought he was a little out of line when he penalised Hooper for a late tackle and putting Treacy on report was also one those petty rulings. The ref and the touch judges also missed a number of blatant cheap shots which were delivered by both teams. 

There were however, some calls from the ref which were crucial. One was the off side call against Luke Branighan in the 47th minute. Luke 'scored' off an in-goal kick but found himself penalised without vid ref replay. It was a very close thing and although Saints' No.7 was out of shot when the kick left the boot, we all feel that he was probably on side. The ref could not have been certain and should have asked for another look. A few minutes later NQ score a try off a forward pass. The ref asked for a vid ref (inevitably it was a 'refs call') - The ref also asked the touch judge as there was some doubt over this. In the end the men on the pitch didn't know and the vid ref wasn't able to decide if a forward pass which is blown back by the wind is in fact a forward pass. Sorry guys, but this is not cricket, we do not give the benefit of the doubt to the batsmen. The pass was forward. Unfortunately, there is a growing trend to award tries when the adjudicators can't decide.  It was worrying to see the ref fall down on his duties when the real hard calls were happening. 

Regardless of this, Oaten kept his head well when dealing with an ill disciplined Saints' team. On one occasion, he was clearly trying to talk to a hot headed Bartrim. There was little doubt that we were about to be penalised and Barto just had to hear out the lecture. Instead he argued the toss and became abusive towards the ref. Oaten was still trying to save the situation but when the expletives started to flow from Bartrim's fat head, the ref had no choice but to send him to the cooler for 10 minutes.

All in all, it was an easy game to referee with little incident in a match that was very one sided. Mark Oaten did well , usually keeping the teams onside and generally putting in a good performance....not a top performance but better than most.
Overall rating: 6½ / 10


Email


WANT TO LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK?
YOUR UNCENSORED MATCH SUMMARY OR REVIEW OR COMMENTARY CAN BE PUBLISHED IN OUR SUPPORTERS LETTERS PAGE ->GO FOR IT!!
To email your opinion click here

| Main Page |
| Team2000 & Best Player | Links & Chat | Supporters Letters | Sound Files |
| How To Play Rugby League in 1964 |